Letâ€™s provide a little background. We Druids have had a stormy relationship with our Idolsâ€”they were either tiresome or difficult to obtain, and their equip effects havenâ€™t always been ideal. Even after Wrath came out, Bears either suffered through content using a Level 70 item as best-in-slot or participated in a series of daily PVP quests to pick up the threat-boosting Idol of Perspicacious Attacks. It wasnâ€™t until Ulduar that Bears cheered the Idol of the Corruptorâ€”and then simultaneously booed when they realized it dropped off of Heroic Vezax. For Cats, life was a little simpler: just pick up the Idol of the Ravenous Beast for a few Emblems of Heroism and then hope you could eventually snag the Idol of Worship from Naxxramas.
Now, just about everything is purchasable with the right sort of currencyâ€”if you know what I meanâ€”including the Idol of the Corruptor and the Idol of Mutilation. But which do you really need, and should you have more than one on hand? The short answer is: YES, ALL OF THEM. But if youâ€™re not crazy, donâ€™t raid very much, or only have the means to obtain one in the near future, the below information will help you get started.
||Effect (Cat Only)
|Idol of the Ravenous Beast
||Increases the damage done by Shred by 203.
|Idol of Worship
||Increases periodic damage done by Rip by 21 per combo point.
|Idol of the Corruptor
||Your Mangle ability has a chance to grant 153 AGI for 12 seconds.
|Idol of Mutilation
||Your Cat Formâ€™s Mangle and Shred abilities have a chance to grant 200 AGI for 16 seconds.
Idol of Worship < ArP 230 < Idol of the Ravenous Beast
Idol of the Corruptor â† Manglebot? â†’ Idol of the Ravenous Beast
Idol of the Ravenous Beast â†ArP > 230 and 25 EoT â†’ Idol of Mutilation
See Above â† Bear â†’ Idol of the Corruptor
What if I swing both ways? Is there a quick answer for Bears?
If you function in any capacity as a Bear tank, I strongly recommend spending the Emblems on the Idol of the Corruptor. For a full and complete breakdown, please see Kalonâ€™s post (and his whole blog, really:) â€œDonâ€™t get Idol of Mutilation for Bear!â€ But wait, you say, doesnâ€™t the Idol of Mutilation give you 200 Dodge Rating for 9 seconds every time you use Swipe or Lacerate? Well, yes. At first glance, it sure does sound better than the Idol of the Corruptor. If you break the numbers down, however, it looks a little like this:
|Idol of the Corruptor
|Idol of Mutilation
Better than you thought, right? Fuck yes, kids. The Agility proc is enhanced by Blessing of Kings, Survival of the Fittest, and Mark of the Wild. With a near 100% uptime for every time you Mangle, you can gain nearly as much Dodge as the Idol of Mutilation boasts, in addition to threat and mitigation boosting stats. And, since the Idol of the Corruptor rolls in at the bargain price of 19 Emblems of Conquest, itâ€™s a steal.
Iâ€™m already sick of looking at the ass end of my bear. Letâ€™s get back to DPS.
Despite all that shit I just said, you should still buy the Idol of Mutilationâ€”but for DPS purposes. Why? Even at a basic level, it makes sense: the Idol of the Ravenous Beast, which most top-end Druids use now, only benefits Shred damage. Previous incarnations of Idols required a Mangle to proc the AGI effect, and with the advent of other abilities that provide bleed augmentations (read: TRAUMA), Cats really werenâ€™t (and still arenâ€™t) Mangling very much at all anymore. The best option was thus to gem for ArP and boost your main damage dealing ability as much as possible: Shred.
The Idol of Mutilation allows you to proc the 200 AGI effect for 16 seconds when you Mangle or Shred. Rather than increasing Shred damage by 203, the Idol of Mutilation amplifies all of your damage dealing attacks by the 200 AGI proc effect. In addition, initial reports suggest that this Idol has a near 100% uptimeâ€”if youâ€™re Shredding and/or Mangling. Presumably, if this functions similarly to the Idol of the Corruptor, the 200 AGI is also affected by Survival of the Fittest, Mark of the Wild, and Blessing of Kings. Thus, that 200 AGI gives you:
So is the Idol of Mutilation better than the Idol of the Ravenous Beast?
This is where it gets complicated, and youâ€™d be best served by taking a peek at one of your most recent damage breakdowns. As a Cat, your goal is to make sure that you keep Savage Roar, Faerie Fire (if you donâ€™t have anyone else who can apply it), Mangle (if you have no bot), Rake and Rip up at all timesâ€”without clipping DoTs. In between all those fun things, you Shred like a mad beast and use Ferocious Bite when youâ€™ve got five combo points and extra time on all your other debuffs/buffs. Thatâ€™s the basic version, anyway.
The idea is that the AGI proc effect will give you the most kapow if youâ€™re spending a reasonable amount of time micromanaging those debuffs/buffsâ€”which will apply to most of us. There is speculation, however, that using two-piece T8 and two-piece T9 (which extend the durations of Rip and Rake, respectively) gives you more time to kick back and Shred. A lot more. If that is the case, the Idol of the Ravenous Beast may once again edge out the Idol of Mutilation.
Additionally, you need to take a look at your total %Crit. Remember Tosskâ€™s DPS Gear Methodology? At some point, AGI (contributing to %crit) loses value to AP. If Coliseum gear pushes Cats (raid buffed and all) well over ~60% Crit, again, the Idol of Mutilation may lose value to the Idol of the Ravenous Beast (which will provide a raw damage increase).
Tentatively, I want to say that the Idol of Mutilation is better than the Idol of the Ravenous Beast. I obviously do not have the capability at this point in time to test those two prior theories out. Once everyone starts acquiring more gear and thereâ€™s a healthier portion of data to dick around with, weâ€™ll have to come back to thisâ€”and please, if youâ€™ve got some sample numbers and corresponding stat information, send it on over!